Guggenheim New York: 1912 — When Paris Turned Painting into Magic Circles

Share this article

JBH Reports on Instagram
JBH Reports on Youtube
JBH Reports on Youtube
JBH Reports on LinkedIn
Share
JBH Reports on Twitter
Visit Us
Follow Me
Subscribe to JBH Reports RSS

Paris: creative effervescence

A nest teeming with artists: Paris was, for nearly a century up until the Second World War, the global epicenter of an unusually creative effervescence. From Camille Corot, who paved the way for the Impressionists, to Marcel Duchamp, a pivotal figure in conceptual art, passing through the likes of Modigliani and Giacometti, the city vibrated with an artistic freedom that had ambitious spirits the world over flocking to Montmartre and Montparnasse.

Guggenheim New York

Guggenheim New York

Naturally, French institutions frequently celebrate this phenomenal period. But this time, it is across the Atlantic that the Guggenheim Museum in New York gives its own resounding tribute, spread over five floors, in its exhibition “Harmony and Dissonance: Orphism in Paris, 1910-1930,” open through March 9.

Vivien Greene

According to co-curator Vivien Greene, the exhibition offers “the first exploration of a movement that sought to break away from Cubism under the aegis of poet Guillaume Apollinaire (1880-1918).” It was, in fact, Apollinaire who coined the term in 1913.

The matter is color

Frantisek Kupka

First and foremost, it is worth noting that the assembly of 82 paintings within the museum’s spiraling galleries offers a visual feast, akin to a fireworks display, since the heart of the matter is color. Or, rather: how paintings exploring the decomposition of light through kaleidoscopic effects gradually evolved toward abstraction.

Orpheus and his lyre

Robert Delaunay

But by focusing too much on the definition of artistic movements, both critic and visitor risk losing their way. Which is how Apollinaire, in spite of his clairvoyant eye, grouped under the Orphist banner—referencing the Greek myth of Orpheus, whose ultimate weapon was his lyre—artists who soon diverged significantly in their artistic pursuits.

Robert Delaunay

Robert Delaunay

The star of the exhibition is Robert Delaunay (1885-1941), to whom a heartbroken Apollinaire ran for solace in 1912, as the story goes. He then commented on his friend’s work by saying “Delaunay was in the process of inventing an art of pure color.”

Frantisek Kupka

Sustain Our Work with a Small Monthly Gift

It’s very simple. Just $10 a month allows us to keep going.
Reliable information is valuable.

Click here to make a donation Make a donation

 Goethe and Seurat

Before him, Seurat, the Neo-Impressionists and even the German writer  Johan Wolfgang von Goethe, had already engaged the question of light decomposition. A crooked Eiffel Tower, symbol of modernity, became the emblem of Delaunay’s polychromatic explorations, rendered at increasingly grand scales.

Jasper Johns

Robert Delaunay

In parallel, as early as 1913, he created an abstract masterpiece, a fiery-toned, round composition entitled “Premier disque” (“First Disc”), the most visually striking piece at the Guggenheim. This painting, which is still held by a private collection, is composed of concentric circles whose hues shift at each quarter-turn. Here we see Delaunay animated by a kind of mystical illumination. It inevitably brings to mind Jasper Johns’ targets created in the 1950s.

Guillaume Apollinaire

Francis Picabia

Apollinaire had highlighted another of his new heroes, František Kupka (1871-1957), a pioneer of abstraction, whose swirling compositions were inspired by music. The exhibition also features paintings from the 1910s by future pranksters Duchamp and Picabia, then obsessed with depicting motion on canvas, as well as a remarkable and atypical tribute by Chagall to Apollinaire in 1913, also disc-shaped.

“Ist” means nothing

Marc Chagall

However, by June 1914, the poet himself no longer believed in his own theory: “We mustn’t take the terms Cubist, Orphist, or Futurist literally anymore. It has been a long time since they’ve meant anything.” Changing one’s mind, as they say, is a sign of intelligence. Meanwhile, the paintings displayed at the Guggenheim, no matter how they are classified, remain as stunning as ever.

Through March 9. www.guggenheim.org

Natalia Goncharova

Share this article

Support independent art journalist

If you value Judith Benhamou Reports, consider supporting our work. Your contribution keeps JB Reports independent and ad-free.

Choose a monthly or one-time donation — even a small amount makes a difference.
You can cancel a recurring donation at any time.

Select Payment Method
Personal Info

Credit Card Info
This is a secure SSL encrypted payment.
Billing Details

Donation Total: 50,00€ for 12

Jan 17, 2025

The Latest :
Leonora Carrington: How a Woman Reinvented Surrealism After the War

Leonora Carrington: How a Woman Reinvented Surrealism After the War

Profound change If the world is undergoing profound change, it is not only in fields related to artificial intelligence or geopolitics. On a far more modest and, of course, less turbulent level, art history too is in the midst of major upheaval. Its impact should not be underestimated. This discipline shapes the way we read […]

TEFAF Maastricht and Its (Almost) Leonardo da Vinci

TEFAF Maastricht and Its (Almost) Leonardo da Vinci

Viral image This image went around the world. In November 2017, Christie’s sold a remarkably rare painting by Leonardo da Vinci, a Salvator Mundi painted around 1500, for $450 million, making it the most expensive work ever sold at auction. The fact that this depiction of Christ by one of the most famous artists of […]

Forget the scandals: discover the Louvre’s new little gallery of wonders

Forget the scandals: discover the Louvre’s new little gallery of wonders

Immense ambitions The Louvre once had immense ambitions. Then came the controversies — the resignation of its president, water leaks, strikes, and even a spectacular burglary — that buried the world’s largest museum under a mountain of problems. As early as 2000, the Pavillon des Sessions had been created at the initiative of Jacques Chirac. In […]

Get a JB Reports subscription today:

Don’t miss a thing. Become a JB subscriber and receive the newsletters as soon as they are published. Judith Benhamou Reports has access to the most influential professionals in the art world, presenting interviews with artists, both recognized and up-and-coming, and offering an insider perspective on fairs and exhibition openings, exclusive videos, and unconventional visits to sites of artistic creation across the globe.